Files
StarPunk/docs/design/v2.20.0/2026-11-13-reply-crossposts.md
T
PhilandClaude Opus 5.5 67c0411fd8 feat: crossposted replies look like replies (v2.20.0)
- Native replies on the same network: GoToSocial in_reply_to_id (resolved
  by our instance) with the author's @mention; Bluesky reply root/parent
- Replies to our own notes (permalink or any crosspost URL) thread under
  that note's crosspost on every network, Threads included
- Otherwise "↩ Replying to <author>" and the link; on Bluesky the name is
  the link. compose_text keeps the line whole when shortening

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-11-13 15:32:14 -07:00

3.6 KiB

v2.20.0: Crossposted replies look like replies

Why

Crossposting ignored in_reply_to. A reply to https://defcon.social/@deviantollam/117611186265622833 went to GoToSocial and Bluesky as an ordinary post (text, permalink, hashtags), with nothing to say it answered anyone.

Behaviour

For each target, in order:

Replying to GoToSocial Bluesky Threads
One of our notes (its page, or a crosspost of it on any network) Native reply to that note's GoToSocial status Native reply to its Bluesky post Native reply (reply_to_id) to its Threads post
A fediverse post Native reply (in_reply_to_id, resolved by our instance) starting with @acct Reply line Reply line
A Bluesky post Reply line Native reply (reply.root/reply.parent) Reply line
Anything else Reply line Reply line Reply line

The reply line is ↩ Replying to <who>, where who is the reply context's author name, else its title, else the URL's host:

  • GoToSocial and Threads: the line, then the URL, then a blank line and the note. On Threads the URL counts towards Meta's limit of five links, so the body gets one link fewer.
  • Bluesky: the line without the URL. Who is a link facet to the post, which saves up to ~100 of the 300 characters.

compose_text(..., lead=...) keeps the line whole and shortens the body instead when the post is too long.

The @mention

The user chose to start a native fediverse reply with the author's mention, as Mastodon and GoToSocial clients do. Without it the author isn't notified, and their server may never receive the reply, so it wouldn't show in their thread. There's no mention when replying to our own account (the search result's account id equals verify_credentials), or when the note already contains the mention.

Our own posts

_own_note_id(url) maps a URL to a note: a synced syndications.remote_url on any target, or /note/<slug> and /article/<slug> on this site. _reply_fields then takes that note's remote_id on the target being posted to, as Post.reply_remote_id. GoToSocial skips the ids of favourites and boosts (favourite:…, reblog:…). Bluesky only takes app.bsky.feed.post URIs. Threads only takes numeric media ids. The Threads API can't look up other people's posts by URL, so only our own posts thread there.

Bluesky threads

A reply's root must be the top of the thread. The parent is fetched with app.bsky.feed.getPosts. If the parent is itself a reply, its record.reply.root is used; otherwise the parent is the root.

Not changed

  • Crossposts made before this release. Edits can't move a status into a thread (GoToSocial, Mastodon), and Bluesky and Threads posts can't be edited at all. Re-threading would mean deleting and reposting, which loses likes and boosts. The user chose to leave them.
  • An edit of a reply on GoToSocial keeps the status where it is, and its text keeps the mention (_prepare resolves the parent again).
  • Fediverse authors bridged into Bluesky by Bridgy Fed have a copy of their post there. There is no reliable way to find its URI from the original URL, so these get the reply line.

Tests

tests/test_reply_crossposts.py: native fediverse reply with mention, no mention for our own account, reply line with name and host fallback, Bluesky root/parent, Bluesky reply line with its link facet, Threads native reply only to our own posts, the line surviving shortening, and a reply to our own note threading on GoToSocial and Bluesky. The reply is addressed both by the note's permalink and by its GoToSocial crosspost URL.