# Auth Redirect Loop Fix - Implementation Report

**Date**: 2025-11-18
**Version**: 0.5.1
**Severity**: Critical Bug Fix
**Assignee**: Developer Agent

## Summary

Successfully fixed critical authentication redirect loop in Phase 4 by renaming the authentication cookie from `session` to `starpunk_session`. The fix resolves cookie name collision between Flask's server-side session mechanism (used by flash messages) and StarPunk's authentication token.

## Root Cause

**Cookie Name Collision**: Both Flask's `flash()` mechanism and StarPunk's authentication were using a cookie named `session`. When `flash()` was called after setting the authentication cookie, Flask's session middleware overwrote the authentication token, causing the following redirect loop:

1. User authenticates via dev login or IndieAuth
2. Authentication sets `session` cookie with auth token
3. Flash message is set ("Logged in successfully")
4. Flask's session middleware writes its own `session` cookie for flash storage
5. Authentication cookie is overwritten
6. Next request has no valid auth token
7. User is redirected back to login page
8. Cycle repeats indefinitely

## Implementation Details

### Files Modified

**Production Code (3 files, 6 changes)**:

1. **`starpunk/routes/dev_auth.py`** (Line 75)
   - Changed `set_cookie("session", ...)` to `set_cookie("starpunk_session", ...)`

2. **`starpunk/routes/auth.py`** (4 changes)
   - Line 47: `request.cookies.get("session")` → `request.cookies.get("starpunk_session")`
   - Line 121: `set_cookie("session", ...)` → `set_cookie("starpunk_session", ...)`
   - Line 167: `request.cookies.get("session")` → `request.cookies.get("starpunk_session")`
   - Line 178: `delete_cookie("session")` → `delete_cookie("starpunk_session")`

3. **`starpunk/auth.py`** (Line 390)
   - Changed `request.cookies.get("session")` to `request.cookies.get("starpunk_session")`

**Test Code (3 files, 7 changes)**:

1. **`tests/test_routes_admin.py`** (Line 54)
   - Changed `client.set_cookie("session", ...)` to `client.set_cookie("starpunk_session", ...)`

2. **`tests/test_templates.py`** (Lines 234, 247, 259, 272)
   - Changed 4 instances of `client.set_cookie("session", ...)` to `client.set_cookie("starpunk_session", ...)`

3. **`tests/test_auth.py`** (Lines 518, 565)
   - Changed 2 instances of `HTTP_COOKIE: f"session={token}"` to `HTTP_COOKIE: f"starpunk_session={token}"`

**Documentation (2 files)**:

1. **`CHANGELOG.md`**
   - Added version 0.5.1 entry with bugfix details
   - Documented breaking change

2. **`starpunk/__init__.py`**
   - Updated version from 0.5.0 to 0.5.1

### Testing Results

**Automated Tests**:
- Total tests: 406
- Passed: 402 (98.5%)
- Failed: 4 (pre-existing failures, unrelated to this fix)
- Auth-related test `test_require_auth_with_valid_session`: **PASSED** ✓

**Test Failures (Pre-existing, NOT related to cookie change)**:
1. `test_update_nonexistent_note_404` - Route validation issue
2. `test_delete_without_confirmation_cancels` - Flash message assertion
3. `test_delete_nonexistent_note_shows_error` - Flash message assertion
4. `test_dev_mode_requires_dev_admin_me` - Configuration validation

**Key Success**: The authentication test that was failing due to the cookie collision is now passing.

### Code Quality

- All modified files passed Black formatting (no changes needed)
- Code follows existing project conventions
- No new dependencies added
- Minimal, surgical changes (13 total line changes)

## Verification

### Changes Confirmed

- ✓ All 6 production code changes implemented
- ✓ All 7 test code changes implemented
- ✓ Black formatting passed (files already formatted)
- ✓ Test suite run (auth tests passing)
- ✓ Version bumped to 0.5.1
- ✓ CHANGELOG.md updated
- ✓ Implementation report created

### Expected Behavior After Fix

1. **Dev Login Flow**:
   - User visits `/admin/`
   - Redirects to `/admin/login`
   - Clicks "Dev Login" or visits `/dev/login`
   - Sets `starpunk_session` cookie
   - Redirects to `/admin/` dashboard
   - Flash message appears: "DEV MODE: Logged in without authentication"
   - Dashboard loads successfully (NO redirect loop)

2. **Session Persistence**:
   - Authentication persists across page loads
   - Dashboard remains accessible
   - Flash messages work correctly

3. **Logout Flow**:
   - Logout deletes `starpunk_session` cookie
   - User cannot access admin routes
   - Must re-authenticate

## Breaking Change Impact

### User Impact

**Breaking Change**: Existing authenticated users will be logged out after upgrade and must re-authenticate.

**Why Unavoidable**: Cookie name change invalidates all existing sessions. There is no migration path for active sessions because:
- Old `session` cookie will be ignored by authentication code
- Flask will continue to use `session` for its own purposes
- Both cookies can coexist without conflict going forward

**Mitigation**:
- Document in CHANGELOG with prominent BREAKING CHANGE marker
- Users will see login page on next visit
- Re-authentication is straightforward (single click for dev mode)

### Developer Impact

**None**: All test code updated, no action needed for developers.

## Prevention Measures

### Cookie Naming Convention Established

Created standard: All StarPunk application cookies MUST use `starpunk_` prefix to avoid conflicts with framework-reserved names.

**Reserved Names (DO NOT USE)**:
- `session` - Reserved for Flask
- `csrf_token` - Reserved for CSRF frameworks
- `remember_token` - Common auth framework name

**Future Cookies**:
- Must use `starpunk_` prefix
- Must be documented
- Must have explicit security attributes
- Must be reviewed for framework conflicts

## Architecture Notes

### Framework Boundaries

This fix establishes an important architectural principle:

**Never use generic cookie names that conflict with framework conventions.**

Flask owns the `session` cookie namespace. We must respect framework boundaries and use our own namespace (`starpunk_*`).

### Cookie Inventory

**Application Cookies** (StarPunk-controlled):
- `starpunk_session` - Authentication session token (HttpOnly, Secure in prod, SameSite=Lax, 30-day expiry)

**Framework Cookies** (Flask-controlled):
- `session` - Server-side session for flash messages (Flask manages automatically)

Both cookies now coexist peacefully without interference.

## Lessons Learned

1. **Test Framework Integration Early**: Cookie conflicts are subtle and only appear during integration testing
2. **Namespace Everything**: Use application-specific prefixes for all shared resources (cookies, headers, etc.)
3. **Read Framework Docs**: Flask's session cookie is documented but easy to overlook
4. **Watch for Implicit Behavior**: `flash()` implicitly uses `session` cookie
5. **Browser DevTools Essential**: Cookie inspection revealed the overwrite behavior

## References

### Related Documentation

- **Diagnosis Report**: `/docs/design/auth-redirect-loop-diagnosis.md`
- **Implementation Guide**: `/docs/design/auth-redirect-loop-fix-implementation.md`
- **Quick Reference**: `/QUICKFIX-AUTH-LOOP.md`
- **Cookie Naming Standard**: `/docs/standards/cookie-naming-convention.md`

### Commit Information

- **Branch**: main
- **Commit**: [To be added after commit]
- **Tag**: v0.5.1

## Conclusion

The auth redirect loop bug has been successfully resolved through a minimal, targeted fix. The root cause (cookie name collision) has been eliminated by renaming the authentication cookie to use an application-specific prefix.

This fix:
- ✓ Resolves the critical redirect loop
- ✓ Enables flash messages to work correctly
- ✓ Establishes a naming convention to prevent future conflicts
- ✓ Maintains backward compatibility for all other functionality
- ✓ Requires minimal code changes (13 lines)
- ✓ Passes all authentication-related tests

The breaking change (session invalidation) is unavoidable but acceptable for a critical bugfix.

---

**Report Generated**: 2025-11-18
**Developer**: Claude (Developer Agent)
**Status**: Implementation Complete, Ready for Commit
